{"schema_version":1,"title":"When the response makes the outage worse","scope":"Recorded synthetic enterprise experiment. Replay of saved outputs; no live simulation runs in the browser.","synthetic_enterprise":"Fictional two-region energy utility on the IEEE 39-bus reference network. No measured company data or calibration.","chart":{"x_key":"t_s","x_unit":"seconds","x_label":"Simulated time (hours)","horizon_s":21600.0,"first_sample_s":0,"last_sample_s":21570,"original_sample_interval_s":30,"original_points_per_policy":720,"display_sampling":"At most 100 original samples per policy. Uniform selection plus points around the physical trip, policy action and cyber onset; no re-simulation or interpolation in this file.","primary_y_key":"unserved_mw","primary_y_label":"Unserved demand (MW)","service_y_key":"service_down_count","service_y_label":"Enterprise services unavailable (count)","fields":{"demand_mw":"Demand, MW","served_mw":"Served demand, MW","unserved_mw":"Unserved demand, MW","service_down_count":"Count of unavailable enterprise services","comms_down_sites":"Sites with communications down","units_online":"Online generating units","branches_out":"Branches unavailable","collapsed_islands":"Collapsed electrical islands"}},"events":[{"id":"physical-trip","t_s":1649.4187489552285,"label":"Injected physical line trip","detail":"Physical contingency, common to all three policies."},{"id":"policy-pivot","t_s":1695.0,"label":"Baseline orders another circuit open","detail":"Operator command recorded at this time; the switch event is logged at 1,696 s."},{"id":"cyber-onset","t_s":11590.049784274866,"label":"First injected cyber effect begins","detail":"Enterprise service outage begins. This is later than the principal cascade."}],"causal_confound":{"title":"The cascade starts before the cyber disruption","text":"In this selected scenario, the baseline acts about 46 seconds after an injected physical trip and about 2.75 hours before any injected cyber effect. The comparison concerns modeled response doctrine under combined stress. It does not isolate cyber causation.","physical_to_command_s":45.581251044771534,"command_before_cyber_s":9895.049784274866,"timing_precision_note":"Physical trip and cyber start use scheduled times. Event logs are recorded on simulator steps; the physical trip appears at 1,650 s and the circuit-open execution at 1,696 s."},"policy_note":"No operator action leaves automatic frequency control and five-minute security-constrained redispatch active. It removes only the operator policy layer.","series":[{"id":"baseline","label":"Rule-based baseline","color":"#e06c57","samples":[{"t_s":0.0,"demand_mw":4305.134388167649,"served_mw":4305.134388167649,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":270.0,"demand_mw":4299.492814707501,"served_mw":4299.492814707501,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":510.0,"demand_mw":4303.937390647782,"served_mw":4303.937390647782,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":780.0,"demand_mw":4344.6284156976235,"served_mw":4344.6284156976235,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1020.0,"demand_mw":4377.89974555577,"served_mw":4377.89974555577,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1290.0,"demand_mw":4374.244679038175,"served_mw":4374.2446790381755,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1530.0,"demand_mw":4373.140044225783,"served_mw":4373.140044225783,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1620.0,"demand_mw":4370.736483090201,"served_mw":4370.736483090201,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1650.0,"demand_mw":4372.140268394825,"served_mw":4060.1092125665955,"unserved_mw":312.0310558282304,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":1680.0,"demand_mw":4373.544053699451,"served_mw":4061.4128124737113,"unserved_mw":312.1312412257404,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":1710.0,"demand_mw":4379.599859509333,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4379.599859509333,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":1740.0,"demand_mw":4385.655665319215,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4385.655665319215,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":1800.0,"demand_mw":4369.942052935366,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4369.942052935366,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":2040.0,"demand_mw":4416.922058067014,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4416.922058067015,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":2310.0,"demand_mw":4390.298337353977,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4390.298337353977,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":1,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":2580.0,"demand_mw":4405.067906197199,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4405.067906197199,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":2,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":2820.0,"demand_mw":4389.051026117839,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4389.05102611784,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":3090.0,"demand_mw":4351.861291152892,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4351.861291152893,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":3330.0,"demand_mw":4363.7923733566495,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4363.79237335665,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":3600.0,"demand_mw":4391.669281100848,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4391.669281100849,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":3840.0,"demand_mw":4309.833912602862,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4309.833912602861,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":4110.0,"demand_mw":4277.210116695891,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4277.210116695891,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":4380.0,"demand_mw":4275.853244161821,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4275.853244161821,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":4620.0,"demand_mw":4283.928095941472,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4283.928095941472,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":4890.0,"demand_mw":4263.459140732225,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4263.459140732224,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":5130.0,"demand_mw":4247.921958407272,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4247.921958407272,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":5400.0,"demand_mw":4213.7535207264855,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4213.753520726486,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":5640.0,"demand_mw":4222.269533304523,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4222.269533304523,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":5910.0,"demand_mw":4255.172813396618,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4255.172813396618,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":6150.0,"demand_mw":4233.788683031633,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4233.788683031633,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":6420.0,"demand_mw":4224.187613263143,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4224.187613263143,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":6690.0,"demand_mw":4234.250384468471,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4234.250384468472,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":6930.0,"demand_mw":4248.161723511803,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4248.161723511804,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":7200.0,"demand_mw":4195.811876643746,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4195.811876643746,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":7440.0,"demand_mw":4179.509720334245,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4179.509720334245,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":7710.0,"demand_mw":4200.927589457238,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4200.927589457239,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":7950.0,"demand_mw":4162.576777285532,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4162.576777285533,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":8220.0,"demand_mw":4126.05734878252,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4126.057348782521,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":4,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":8460.0,"demand_mw":4105.638110694591,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4105.63811069459,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":8730.0,"demand_mw":4070.3194718953428,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4070.3194718953428,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":9000.0,"demand_mw":4035.2439707725543,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4035.2439707725557,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":9240.0,"demand_mw":4031.122224487096,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4031.122224487095,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":9510.0,"demand_mw":4007.142454539411,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":4007.142454539412,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":9750.0,"demand_mw":3989.482683637725,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3989.482683637725,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":10020.0,"demand_mw":3966.9586869402037,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3966.958686940205,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":10260.0,"demand_mw":3932.903129195046,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3932.9031291950464,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":10530.0,"demand_mw":3924.507449457413,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3924.5074494574137,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":10800.0,"demand_mw":3939.21753516016,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3939.2175351601604,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":11040.0,"demand_mw":3893.659961641443,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3893.6599616414433,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":11310.0,"demand_mw":3894.22457141865,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3894.22457141865,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":11550.0,"demand_mw":3861.0159461225635,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3861.015946122564,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":11580.0,"demand_mw":3857.854502725926,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3857.854502725927,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":11610.0,"demand_mw":3842.857374035859,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3842.8573740358597,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":11820.0,"demand_mw":3834.9097078870227,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3834.909707887023,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":11880.0,"demand_mw":3822.7683177484246,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3822.7683177484246,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":10,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":12060.0,"demand_mw":3777.4815839613443,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3777.4815839613443,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":12300.0,"demand_mw":3767.7136951815246,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3767.7136951815232,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":12330.0,"demand_mw":3769.8216250364612,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3769.821625036461,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":12570.0,"demand_mw":3712.884775897626,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3712.884775897626,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":12840.0,"demand_mw":3691.4936028270677,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3691.4936028270677,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":13110.0,"demand_mw":3641.069957051727,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3641.0699570517268,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":13350.0,"demand_mw":3628.8972642195877,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3628.8972642195877,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":13620.0,"demand_mw":3591.205460852859,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3591.2054608528592,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":13860.0,"demand_mw":3576.4872895621293,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3576.48728956213,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":14130.0,"demand_mw":3516.4097676102147,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3516.4097676102147,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":14370.0,"demand_mw":3474.7081657308936,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3474.7081657308936,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":14640.0,"demand_mw":3458.1661105868952,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3458.1661105868957,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":14880.0,"demand_mw":3474.7235816369866,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3474.723581636987,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":15150.0,"demand_mw":3454.07652486351,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3454.0765248635093,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":15420.0,"demand_mw":3422.1672924912805,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3422.167292491281,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":15660.0,"demand_mw":3386.904727809437,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3386.904727809437,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":15930.0,"demand_mw":3344.5297237368763,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3344.529723736877,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":16170.0,"demand_mw":3311.7462970183615,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3311.7462970183615,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":16440.0,"demand_mw":3281.757642595181,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3281.7576425951816,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":16680.0,"demand_mw":3253.8276936324805,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3253.827693632482,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":16950.0,"demand_mw":3250.390920343656,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3250.3909203436556,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":17190.0,"demand_mw":3248.8878377137876,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3248.887837713787,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":17460.0,"demand_mw":3214.8175159093194,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3214.81751590932,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":17730.0,"demand_mw":3217.9489456425736,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3217.948945642574,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":17970.0,"demand_mw":3199.1288932010766,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3199.128893201077,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":18240.0,"demand_mw":3168.3899446177375,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3168.3899446177375,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":18480.0,"demand_mw":3177.302149791649,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3177.3021497916498,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":18750.0,"demand_mw":3115.5454758677542,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3115.5454758677542,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":18990.0,"demand_mw":3071.935827919989,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":3071.935827919989,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":19260.0,"demand_mw":2994.931504276403,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":2994.9315042764033,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":19530.0,"demand_mw":2940.611293257823,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":2940.6112932578226,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":19770.0,"demand_mw":2950.7332381268698,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":2950.7332381268698,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":20040.0,"demand_mw":2957.6768395915296,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":2957.6768395915296,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":20280.0,"demand_mw":2966.046495194085,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":2966.0464951940853,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":20550.0,"demand_mw":2959.1099304290296,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":2959.10993042903,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":20790.0,"demand_mw":2966.4513517802993,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":2966.4513517803,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":21060.0,"demand_mw":2921.3834817738107,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":2921.38348177381,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":21300.0,"demand_mw":2914.4489237047287,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":2914.4489237047287,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3},{"t_s":21570.0,"demand_mw":2913.496463282334,"served_mw":0.0,"unserved_mw":2913.496463282335,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":13,"units_online":0,"branches_out":4,"collapsed_islands":3}],"outcome":{"unserved_mwh":20686.239328382748,"demand_mwh":22730.683733149257,"unserved_pct":91.00579450769007,"critical_load_continuity_pct":9.013096598721216,"generator_trips":10.0,"branch_trips":4.0,"actions":26.0,"redispatch_successes":5,"redispatch_failures":66}},{"id":"coordinated","label":"Coordinated response","color":"#55b4d0","samples":[{"t_s":0.0,"demand_mw":4305.134388167649,"served_mw":4305.134388167649,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":270.0,"demand_mw":4299.492814707501,"served_mw":4299.492814707501,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":510.0,"demand_mw":4303.937390647782,"served_mw":4303.937390647782,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":780.0,"demand_mw":4344.6284156976235,"served_mw":4344.6284156976235,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1020.0,"demand_mw":4377.89974555577,"served_mw":4377.89974555577,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1290.0,"demand_mw":4374.244679038175,"served_mw":4374.2446790381755,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1530.0,"demand_mw":4373.140044225783,"served_mw":4373.140044225783,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1620.0,"demand_mw":4370.736483090201,"served_mw":4370.736483090201,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1650.0,"demand_mw":4372.140268394825,"served_mw":4060.1092125665955,"unserved_mw":312.0310558282304,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":1680.0,"demand_mw":4373.544053699451,"served_mw":4061.4128124737113,"unserved_mw":312.1312412257404,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":1710.0,"demand_mw":4379.599859509333,"served_mw":4067.036427327963,"unserved_mw":312.5634321813709,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":1740.0,"demand_mw":4385.655665319215,"served_mw":4072.660042182214,"unserved_mw":312.9956231370014,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":1800.0,"demand_mw":4369.942052935366,"served_mw":4058.0678794230366,"unserved_mw":311.87417351232864,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":2040.0,"demand_mw":4416.922058067014,"served_mw":3738.7100688035052,"unserved_mw":678.2119892635103,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":2310.0,"demand_mw":4390.298337353977,"served_mw":3839.881598977047,"unserved_mw":550.4167383769304,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":2580.0,"demand_mw":4405.067906197199,"served_mw":3812.164082131894,"unserved_mw":592.9038240653051,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":2820.0,"demand_mw":4389.051026117839,"served_mw":3810.7025128839437,"unserved_mw":578.3485132338967,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":3090.0,"demand_mw":4351.861291152892,"served_mw":3857.2350935804625,"unserved_mw":494.6261975724301,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":3330.0,"demand_mw":4363.7923733566495,"served_mw":3736.5025675296642,"unserved_mw":627.2898058269869,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":3600.0,"demand_mw":4391.669281100848,"served_mw":3760.3722039488825,"unserved_mw":631.297077151966,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":3840.0,"demand_mw":4309.833912602862,"served_mw":3751.2282921013352,"unserved_mw":558.6056205015261,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":4110.0,"demand_mw":4277.210116695891,"served_mw":3689.853186655792,"unserved_mw":587.3569300400991,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":4380.0,"demand_mw":4275.853244161821,"served_mw":3727.846320524741,"unserved_mw":548.0069236370808,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":4620.0,"demand_mw":4283.928095941472,"served_mw":3714.8427956143246,"unserved_mw":569.0853003271473,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":4890.0,"demand_mw":4263.459140732225,"served_mw":3734.706099949377,"unserved_mw":528.7530407828475,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":5130.0,"demand_mw":4247.921958407272,"served_mw":3730.91615588012,"unserved_mw":517.0058025271508,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":5400.0,"demand_mw":4213.7535207264855,"served_mw":3700.906288134757,"unserved_mw":512.8472325917284,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":5640.0,"demand_mw":4222.269533304523,"served_mw":3700.4929021574258,"unserved_mw":521.7766311470972,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":5910.0,"demand_mw":4255.172813396618,"served_mw":3725.504822754154,"unserved_mw":529.6679906424641,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":6150.0,"demand_mw":4233.788683031633,"served_mw":3744.1058891657326,"unserved_mw":489.68279386590046,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":6420.0,"demand_mw":4224.187613263143,"served_mw":3764.401055017675,"unserved_mw":459.7865582454688,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":6690.0,"demand_mw":4234.250384468471,"served_mw":3732.2983553264085,"unserved_mw":501.95202914206334,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":6930.0,"demand_mw":4248.161723511803,"served_mw":3706.530530678887,"unserved_mw":541.6311928329164,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":7200.0,"demand_mw":4195.811876643746,"served_mw":3660.8551731191897,"unserved_mw":534.9567035245558,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":7440.0,"demand_mw":4179.509720334245,"served_mw":3699.4474869909354,"unserved_mw":480.06223334330946,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":7710.0,"demand_mw":4200.927589457238,"served_mw":3736.420504516207,"unserved_mw":464.5070849410324,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":7950.0,"demand_mw":4162.576777285532,"served_mw":3600.602014355847,"unserved_mw":561.9747629296863,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":8220.0,"demand_mw":4126.05734878252,"served_mw":3623.6436650482365,"unserved_mw":502.41368373428503,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":8460.0,"demand_mw":4105.638110694591,"served_mw":3605.7107968188902,"unserved_mw":499.92731387570035,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":8730.0,"demand_mw":4070.3194718953428,"served_mw":3566.215530464881,"unserved_mw":504.1039414304615,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":9000.0,"demand_mw":4035.2439707725543,"served_mw":3535.484085990652,"unserved_mw":499.7598847819026,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":9240.0,"demand_mw":4031.122224487096,"served_mw":3544.8371823125954,"unserved_mw":486.28504217449995,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":9510.0,"demand_mw":4007.142454539411,"served_mw":3537.507733755545,"unserved_mw":469.6347207838671,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":9750.0,"demand_mw":3989.482683637725,"served_mw":3521.9176775372293,"unserved_mw":467.56500610049585,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":10020.0,"demand_mw":3966.9586869402037,"served_mw":3521.276392032032,"unserved_mw":445.68229490817225,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":10260.0,"demand_mw":3932.903129195046,"served_mw":3522.7504953545194,"unserved_mw":410.1526338405268,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":10530.0,"demand_mw":3924.507449457413,"served_mw":3482.79810667451,"unserved_mw":441.7093427829035,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":10800.0,"demand_mw":3939.21753516016,"served_mw":3495.8525496318375,"unserved_mw":443.3649855283235,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11040.0,"demand_mw":3893.659961641443,"served_mw":3449.041206294421,"unserved_mw":444.618755347022,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11310.0,"demand_mw":3894.22457141865,"served_mw":3471.072037890527,"unserved_mw":423.15253352812323,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11550.0,"demand_mw":3861.0159461225635,"served_mw":3456.8058453013286,"unserved_mw":404.21010082123536,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11580.0,"demand_mw":3857.854502725926,"served_mw":3453.9753736934454,"unserved_mw":403.8791290324816,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11610.0,"demand_mw":3842.857374035859,"served_mw":3440.5482957321065,"unserved_mw":402.3090783037534,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11820.0,"demand_mw":3834.9097078870227,"served_mw":3477.4465160912396,"unserved_mw":357.4631917957837,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11880.0,"demand_mw":3822.7683177484246,"served_mw":3466.4368605702393,"unserved_mw":356.331457178185,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":12060.0,"demand_mw":3777.4815839613443,"served_mw":3387.6687033557964,"unserved_mw":389.8128806055477,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":12300.0,"demand_mw":3767.7136951815246,"served_mw":3378.9088006582547,"unserved_mw":388.8048945232691,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":12330.0,"demand_mw":3769.8216250364612,"served_mw":3393.0799693042222,"unserved_mw":376.7416557322386,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":12570.0,"demand_mw":3712.884775897626,"served_mw":3341.8331726268307,"unserved_mw":371.05160327079506,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":12840.0,"demand_mw":3691.4936028270677,"served_mw":3333.0520575169407,"unserved_mw":358.4415453101264,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":13110.0,"demand_mw":3641.069957051727,"served_mw":3287.524513822894,"unserved_mw":353.5454432288328,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":13350.0,"demand_mw":3628.8972642195877,"served_mw":3276.5337812753387,"unserved_mw":352.36348294424886,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":13620.0,"demand_mw":3591.205460852859,"served_mw":3242.501826657623,"unserved_mw":348.7036341952361,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":13860.0,"demand_mw":3576.4872895621293,"served_mw":3229.2127798972865,"unserved_mw":347.2745096648432,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":14130.0,"demand_mw":3516.4097676102147,"served_mw":3174.968744908577,"unserved_mw":341.44102270163796,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":14370.0,"demand_mw":3474.7081657308936,"served_mw":3137.316340516171,"unserved_mw":337.39182521472253,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":14640.0,"demand_mw":3458.1661105868952,"served_mw":3122.380507797665,"unserved_mw":335.78560278923084,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":14880.0,"demand_mw":3474.7235816369866,"served_mw":3137.3302595481546,"unserved_mw":337.39332208883286,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":15150.0,"demand_mw":3454.07652486351,"served_mw":3118.6880180966705,"unserved_mw":335.38850676683865,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":15420.0,"demand_mw":3422.1672924912805,"served_mw":3089.8771507202264,"unserved_mw":332.2901417710542,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":15660.0,"demand_mw":3386.904727809437,"served_mw":3058.038557345412,"unserved_mw":328.866170464026,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":15930.0,"demand_mw":3344.5297237368763,"served_mw":3019.7781376596854,"unserved_mw":324.7515860771916,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":16170.0,"demand_mw":3311.7462970183615,"served_mw":2990.1779596198476,"unserved_mw":321.5683373985139,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":16440.0,"demand_mw":3281.757642595181,"served_mw":2963.1011833657058,"unserved_mw":318.6564592294759,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":16680.0,"demand_mw":3253.8276936324805,"served_mw":2937.883213656866,"unserved_mw":315.944479975616,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":16950.0,"demand_mw":3250.390920343656,"served_mw":2934.7801487422284,"unserved_mw":315.61077160142753,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":17190.0,"demand_mw":3248.8878377137876,"served_mw":2933.423014424492,"unserved_mw":315.4648232892954,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":17460.0,"demand_mw":3214.8175159093194,"served_mw":2902.6608979457637,"unserved_mw":312.15661796355556,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":17730.0,"demand_mw":3217.9489456425736,"served_mw":2905.48826795865,"unserved_mw":312.46067768392413,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":17970.0,"demand_mw":3199.1288932010766,"served_mw":2888.4956299476644,"unserved_mw":310.63326325341245,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":18240.0,"demand_mw":3168.3899446177375,"served_mw":2860.7414125915398,"unserved_mw":307.64853202619776,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":18480.0,"demand_mw":3177.302149791649,"served_mw":2868.788248638925,"unserved_mw":308.5139011527247,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":18750.0,"demand_mw":3115.5454758677542,"served_mw":2813.028106205032,"unserved_mw":302.51736966272244,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":18990.0,"demand_mw":3071.935827919989,"served_mw":2773.652925733753,"unserved_mw":298.28290218623636,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":19260.0,"demand_mw":2994.931504276403,"served_mw":2704.1256701097973,"unserved_mw":290.8058341666061,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":19530.0,"demand_mw":2940.611293257823,"served_mw":2655.079915036138,"unserved_mw":285.53137822168424,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":19770.0,"demand_mw":2950.7332381268698,"served_mw":2664.219025868137,"unserved_mw":286.5142122587327,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":20040.0,"demand_mw":2957.6768395915296,"served_mw":2670.488408302022,"unserved_mw":287.1884312895078,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":20280.0,"demand_mw":2966.046495194085,"served_mw":2678.045375976419,"unserved_mw":288.00111921766677,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":20550.0,"demand_mw":2959.1099304290296,"served_mw":2671.782346983341,"unserved_mw":287.3275834456892,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":20790.0,"demand_mw":2966.4513517802993,"served_mw":2678.4109212604867,"unserved_mw":288.040430519813,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":21060.0,"demand_mw":2921.3834817738107,"served_mw":2637.719111111338,"unserved_mw":283.6643706624722,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":21300.0,"demand_mw":2914.4489237047287,"served_mw":2631.4578939654057,"unserved_mw":282.9910297393236,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":21570.0,"demand_mw":2913.496463282334,"served_mw":2630.5979168092395,"unserved_mw":282.89854647309545,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1}],"outcome":{"unserved_mwh":2302.734953615137,"demand_mwh":22730.683733149257,"unserved_pct":10.130513365319262,"critical_load_continuity_pct":99.23549253074599,"generator_trips":1.0,"branch_trips":1.0,"actions":8.0,"redispatch_successes":71,"redispatch_failures":0}},{"id":"no-action","label":"No operator action","color":"#a4b7b0","samples":[{"t_s":0.0,"demand_mw":4305.134388167649,"served_mw":4305.134388167649,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":270.0,"demand_mw":4299.492814707501,"served_mw":4299.492814707501,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":510.0,"demand_mw":4303.937390647782,"served_mw":4303.937390647782,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":780.0,"demand_mw":4344.6284156976235,"served_mw":4344.6284156976235,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1020.0,"demand_mw":4377.89974555577,"served_mw":4377.89974555577,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1290.0,"demand_mw":4374.244679038175,"served_mw":4374.2446790381755,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1530.0,"demand_mw":4373.140044225783,"served_mw":4373.140044225783,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1620.0,"demand_mw":4370.736483090201,"served_mw":4370.736483090201,"unserved_mw":0.0,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":10,"branches_out":0,"collapsed_islands":0},{"t_s":1650.0,"demand_mw":4372.140268394825,"served_mw":4060.1092125665955,"unserved_mw":312.0310558282304,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":1680.0,"demand_mw":4373.544053699451,"served_mw":4061.4128124737113,"unserved_mw":312.1312412257404,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":1710.0,"demand_mw":4379.599859509333,"served_mw":4067.036427327963,"unserved_mw":312.5634321813709,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":1740.0,"demand_mw":4385.655665319215,"served_mw":4072.660042182214,"unserved_mw":312.9956231370014,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":1800.0,"demand_mw":4369.942052935366,"served_mw":4058.0678794230366,"unserved_mw":311.87417351232864,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":2040.0,"demand_mw":4416.922058067014,"served_mw":3743.233655245553,"unserved_mw":673.6884028214622,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":2310.0,"demand_mw":4390.298337353977,"served_mw":3841.879712177433,"unserved_mw":548.418625176545,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":2580.0,"demand_mw":4405.067906197199,"served_mw":3813.0739592513687,"unserved_mw":591.9939469458304,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":2820.0,"demand_mw":4389.051026117839,"served_mw":3813.579297893248,"unserved_mw":575.4717282245921,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":3090.0,"demand_mw":4351.861291152892,"served_mw":3857.873958964333,"unserved_mw":493.9873321885599,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":3330.0,"demand_mw":4363.7923733566495,"served_mw":3740.0665902718183,"unserved_mw":623.7257830848325,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":3600.0,"demand_mw":4391.669281100848,"served_mw":3763.958994486725,"unserved_mw":627.7102866141237,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":3840.0,"demand_mw":4309.833912602862,"served_mw":3753.1709270660954,"unserved_mw":556.6629855367663,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":4110.0,"demand_mw":4277.210116695891,"served_mw":3692.834663482914,"unserved_mw":584.3754532129772,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":4380.0,"demand_mw":4275.853244161821,"served_mw":3730.8098451086075,"unserved_mw":545.0433990532136,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":4620.0,"demand_mw":4283.928095941472,"served_mw":3717.3160721651793,"unserved_mw":566.6120237762925,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":4890.0,"demand_mw":4263.459140732225,"served_mw":3736.949887459411,"unserved_mw":526.5092532728131,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":5130.0,"demand_mw":4247.921958407272,"served_mw":3733.2528472384497,"unserved_mw":514.6691111688215,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":5400.0,"demand_mw":4213.7535207264855,"served_mw":3703.224184163549,"unserved_mw":510.5293365629362,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":5640.0,"demand_mw":4222.269533304523,"served_mw":3702.9877022447413,"unserved_mw":519.2818310597821,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":5910.0,"demand_mw":4255.172813396618,"served_mw":3727.6797876851037,"unserved_mw":527.4930257115141,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":6150.0,"demand_mw":4233.788683031633,"served_mw":3746.4629772652615,"unserved_mw":487.3257057663713,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":6420.0,"demand_mw":4224.187613263143,"served_mw":3766.6691473613223,"unserved_mw":457.5184659018215,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":6690.0,"demand_mw":4234.250384468471,"served_mw":3735.032461179925,"unserved_mw":499.2179232885455,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":6930.0,"demand_mw":4248.161723511803,"served_mw":3708.5991404650867,"unserved_mw":539.5625830467163,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":7200.0,"demand_mw":4195.811876643746,"served_mw":3662.8982915487554,"unserved_mw":532.9135850949907,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":7440.0,"demand_mw":4179.509720334245,"served_mw":3702.666819441081,"unserved_mw":476.842900893164,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":7710.0,"demand_mw":4200.927589457238,"served_mw":3738.213902664733,"unserved_mw":462.71368679250645,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":7950.0,"demand_mw":4162.576777285532,"served_mw":3603.0387438569114,"unserved_mw":559.5380334286222,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":8220.0,"demand_mw":4126.05734878252,"served_mw":3625.6281871247443,"unserved_mw":500.42916165777706,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":8460.0,"demand_mw":4105.638110694591,"served_mw":3607.685497793715,"unserved_mw":497.95261290087507,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":8730.0,"demand_mw":4070.3194718953428,"served_mw":3568.184887473254,"unserved_mw":502.1345844220883,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":9000.0,"demand_mw":4035.2439707725543,"served_mw":3537.4364722957584,"unserved_mw":497.8074984767962,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":9240.0,"demand_mw":4031.122224487096,"served_mw":3546.6359716128127,"unserved_mw":484.4862528742825,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":9510.0,"demand_mw":4007.142454539411,"served_mw":3539.4799291035342,"unserved_mw":467.6625254358779,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":9750.0,"demand_mw":3989.482683637725,"served_mw":3523.8811812755703,"unserved_mw":465.60150236215463,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":10020.0,"demand_mw":3966.9586869402037,"served_mw":3523.878621179851,"unserved_mw":443.0800657603535,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":10260.0,"demand_mw":3932.903129195046,"served_mw":3521.452204736666,"unserved_mw":411.4509244583805,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":10530.0,"demand_mw":3924.507449457413,"served_mw":3487.1509938077893,"unserved_mw":437.35645564962397,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":10800.0,"demand_mw":3939.21753516016,"served_mw":3500.2217525304986,"unserved_mw":438.995782629662,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11040.0,"demand_mw":3893.659961641443,"served_mw":3450.5680018674334,"unserved_mw":443.09195977400964,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11310.0,"demand_mw":3894.22457141865,"served_mw":3473.340169309945,"unserved_mw":420.8844021087052,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11550.0,"demand_mw":3861.0159461225635,"served_mw":3456.76547481439,"unserved_mw":404.2504713081742,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11580.0,"demand_mw":3857.854502725926,"served_mw":3453.935036262317,"unserved_mw":403.91946646361043,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11610.0,"demand_mw":3842.857374035859,"served_mw":3440.508115109806,"unserved_mw":402.3492589260535,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11820.0,"demand_mw":3834.9097078870227,"served_mw":3480.2384722559677,"unserved_mw":354.6712356310553,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":11880.0,"demand_mw":3822.7683177484246,"served_mw":3469.2199773536977,"unserved_mw":353.5483403947271,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":12060.0,"demand_mw":3777.4815839613443,"served_mw":3388.951830118417,"unserved_mw":388.5297538429276,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":12300.0,"demand_mw":3767.7136951815246,"served_mw":3116.836613468897,"unserved_mw":650.8770817126272,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":12330.0,"demand_mw":3769.8216250364612,"served_mw":3147.711646411007,"unserved_mw":622.1099786254539,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":12570.0,"demand_mw":3712.884775897626,"served_mw":3100.1707277760243,"unserved_mw":612.7140481216018,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":12840.0,"demand_mw":3691.4936028270677,"served_mw":3082.309605605836,"unserved_mw":609.1839972212306,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":13110.0,"demand_mw":3641.069957051727,"served_mw":3040.2070573029027,"unserved_mw":600.8628997488239,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":13350.0,"demand_mw":3628.8972642195877,"served_mw":3030.0431474931015,"unserved_mw":598.8541167264858,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":13620.0,"demand_mw":3591.205460852859,"served_mw":2998.5713856347306,"unserved_mw":592.6340752181286,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":13860.0,"demand_mw":3576.4872895621293,"served_mw":2986.2820616842237,"unserved_mw":590.2052278779063,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":14130.0,"demand_mw":3516.4097676102147,"served_mw":2936.118755739018,"unserved_mw":580.2910118711969,"service_down_count":2,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":14370.0,"demand_mw":3474.7081657308936,"served_mw":2901.2989072247624,"unserved_mw":573.4092585061312,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":14640.0,"demand_mw":3458.1661105868952,"served_mw":2887.48668351462,"unserved_mw":570.6794270722755,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":14880.0,"demand_mw":3474.7235816369866,"served_mw":2901.3117791407244,"unserved_mw":573.4118024962623,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":15150.0,"demand_mw":3454.07652486351,"served_mw":2884.0719764300707,"unserved_mw":570.0045484334387,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":15420.0,"demand_mw":3422.1672924912805,"served_mw":2857.428524204363,"unserved_mw":564.7387682869178,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":15660.0,"demand_mw":3386.904727809437,"served_mw":2827.9851190325635,"unserved_mw":558.9196087768739,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":15930.0,"demand_mw":3344.5297237368763,"served_mw":2792.602995658325,"unserved_mw":551.9267280785518,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":16170.0,"demand_mw":3311.7462970183615,"served_mw":2765.2296118871145,"unserved_mw":546.5166851312473,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":16440.0,"demand_mw":3281.757642595181,"served_mw":2740.1897966976817,"unserved_mw":541.5678458974996,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":16680.0,"demand_mw":3253.8276936324805,"served_mw":2716.8689517405396,"unserved_mw":536.9587418919416,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":16950.0,"demand_mw":3250.390920343656,"served_mw":2713.9993275558136,"unserved_mw":536.3915927878428,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":17190.0,"demand_mw":3248.8878377137876,"served_mw":2712.7442892091353,"unserved_mw":536.1435485046519,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":17460.0,"demand_mw":3214.8175159093194,"served_mw":2684.296378563003,"unserved_mw":530.5211373463162,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":17730.0,"demand_mw":3217.9489456425736,"served_mw":2686.9110481207936,"unserved_mw":531.0378975217802,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":17970.0,"demand_mw":3199.1288932010766,"served_mw":2671.19675069549,"unserved_mw":527.9321425055874,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":18240.0,"demand_mw":3168.3899446177375,"served_mw":2645.530457677376,"unserved_mw":522.8594869403613,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":18480.0,"demand_mw":3177.302149791649,"served_mw":2652.9719376229577,"unserved_mw":524.3302121686922,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":18750.0,"demand_mw":3115.5454758677542,"served_mw":2601.4065796063232,"unserved_mw":514.1388962614304,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":18990.0,"demand_mw":3071.935827919989,"served_mw":2564.9935578788736,"unserved_mw":506.9422700411155,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":19260.0,"demand_mw":2994.931504276403,"served_mw":2500.6967739814195,"unserved_mw":494.2347302949835,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":19530.0,"demand_mw":2940.611293257823,"served_mw":2455.3406861169083,"unserved_mw":485.2706071409145,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":19770.0,"demand_mw":2950.7332381268698,"served_mw":2463.7922700160066,"unserved_mw":486.94096811086354,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":20040.0,"demand_mw":2957.6768395915296,"served_mw":2469.59001255459,"unserved_mw":488.08682703693984,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":20280.0,"demand_mw":2966.046495194085,"served_mw":2476.578476475972,"unserved_mw":489.46801871811317,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":20550.0,"demand_mw":2959.1099304290296,"served_mw":2470.786609414666,"unserved_mw":488.3233210143642,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":20790.0,"demand_mw":2966.4513517802993,"served_mw":2476.9165221233015,"unserved_mw":489.53482965699794,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":21060.0,"demand_mw":2921.3834817738107,"served_mw":2439.2859195621018,"unserved_mw":482.0975622117085,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":21300.0,"demand_mw":2914.4489237047287,"served_mw":2433.49572804434,"unserved_mw":480.9531956603887,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1},{"t_s":21570.0,"demand_mw":2913.496463282334,"served_mw":2432.700446181558,"unserved_mw":480.7960171007768,"service_down_count":0,"comms_down_sites":0,"units_online":9,"branches_out":1,"collapsed_islands":1}],"outcome":{"unserved_mwh":2880.8500766732222,"demand_mwh":22730.683733149257,"unserved_pct":12.673838193753667,"critical_load_continuity_pct":99.26451145526445,"generator_trips":1.0,"branch_trips":1.0,"actions":0.0,"redispatch_successes":71,"redispatch_failures":0}}],"heldout":{"n_paired_scenarios":4948,"attempted_scenarios":5000,"excluded_scenarios":52,"policies_per_scenario":4,"horizon_s":21600,"metric":"Mean unserved energy as a percentage of total demand over six simulated hours. Lower is better.","interval_note":"95% bootstrap confidence intervals from the supplied final key-results artifact. These are uncertainty intervals for this synthetic sample, not real incident probabilities.","rows":[{"id":"no-action","label":"No operator action","color":"#a4b7b0","n":4948,"unserved_pct":12.405886643330852,"ci95_pct":[11.931153719991407,12.88273497936849]},{"id":"coordinated","label":"Coordinated response","color":"#55b4d0","n":4948,"unserved_pct":12.761320379665372,"ci95_pct":[12.26777808320021,13.251703712748125],"paired_penalty_vs_no_action_points":0.3554337363345183,"paired_penalty_ci95_points":[0.19024017538113078,0.5139767925286641],"share_worse_than_no_action_pct":32.457558609539205},{"id":"baseline","label":"Rule-based baseline","color":"#e06c57","n":4948,"unserved_pct":16.038277045109364,"ci95_pct":[15.447253903279773,16.64496251785512],"paired_penalty_vs_no_action_points":3.6323904017785105,"paired_penalty_ci95_points":[3.27731249789315,3.9933070644270625],"share_worse_than_no_action_pct":44.50282942603072},{"id":"subsystem","label":"Per-subsystem response","color":"#c69bd4","n":4948,"unserved_pct":16.304030556152853,"ci95_pct":[15.770781975230651,16.831555739377247],"paired_penalty_vs_no_action_points":3.898143912821999,"paired_penalty_ci95_points":[3.549509652373635,4.2598855351900236],"share_worse_than_no_action_pct":55.96200485044462}],"conclusion":"Coordinated response improves on the baseline, but none of the tested operator policies beats no operator action on the held-out mean. The selected replay favors coordination more strongly than the held-out population."},"validation":{"checks_passed":23,"checks_total":23,"components":12,"declared_cross_domain_contracts":29,"buses":39,"branches":46,"direct_validation_note":"Six components have no dedicated external or analytic reference check, including the operator policies. Passing the component checks does not validate real enterprise performance."},"negative_findings":[{"finding":"The expected gas-electric cascade did not drive the worst cases.","evidence":"Removing either gas-to-power or power-to-gas coupling changes mean unserved energy by exactly 0 in the 250 selected worst development cases."},{"finding":"Communications isolation was not the dominant damaging reflex.","evidence":"The investigated harm concentrated in the baseline circuit-opening action."}],"sources":["Saved counterfactual traces","Final held-out comparison","Final key results","Component validation report","Written corrections"]}